Here’s a mistake I see new comics make all the time:
They tell me a “joke,” and the setup’s already trying to be funny. It’s jammed full of wordplay or cutesy asides or little chuckle crumbs that say, “Please laugh now so I feel safe.”
Here’s the problem:
If you burn the surprise too early, there’s nowhere for the punchline to go. You just turned a joke into a shrug.
Let’s use one of mine as an example:
Premise: I’m not looking for pity, but just so you’re aware—
Setup: I am handicapped.
Punchline: I was born without an ass.
Simple. Clean. Honest. And here’s the key:
There are zero jokes in the premise. There are zero jokes in the setup.
That’s how you build tension. That’s how you load the slingshot. That’s how you earn the explosion at the end.
And it’s all thanks to the Humor Blueprint — a four-step structure for writing better jokes without accidentally stepping on your own laugh.
🔨 Step 1: Choose a Premise to Make Funny
The premise is not a joke. It’s a frustration, fear, confession, or flaw tied to a topic. You’re not trying to be clever yet. You’re just stating the emotional truth.
Premise: I’m not looking for pity, but just so you’re aware—
That’s not funny. It’s vulnerable. It’s disarming. It makes the audience lean in. That’s what you want. You want them curious and slightly nervous. You want them asking, “Wait… is this gonna be serious?”
Because once they expect sincerity, your twist hits harder.
DO NOT try to sneak a joke in here.
If I’d said:
“I’m not looking for pity, but just so you’re aware—I’ve got the body of a Greek god and the butt of a Ken doll,”
then guess what?
I just gave the punchline away early. And now I’m the setup guy at a birthday party who accidentally eats the cake before the candles are lit.
🪞 Step 2: Use Your Comedy Lens to Find Your Take
Here’s where it gets personal. Your Comedy Lens is the way you view the world — your internal logic, your quirks, your flaws on parade. Mine? I’m the Clumsy Aspy-hole. I overcorrect. I micromanage. I say the thing you’re not supposed to say and then explain it with charts.
So when I say,
“I was born without an ass,”
it’s not just absurd — it’s on-brand. It’s me being medically literal, emotionally awkward, and proudly defective. The audience doesn’t just laugh at the line. They believe it came from me. Because it did.
🧭 Step 3: Choose the Most Effective Norm to Set Up the Twist
This is the real misdirection. You’re pointing the audience toward a norm — a common belief, pattern, or social rule.
Setup: I am handicapped.
Now, again:
There is no joke here. It’s clean. It’s simple. It sets the expectation.
The audience thinks:
“Oh, this is going to be a serious bit about disability.”
You are baiting them. Not mocking them. Not tricking them.
You’re using shared assumptions to guide their expectations just far enough so that when the punchline arrives, it flips them.
Most comics ruin this moment by getting nervous and adding fluff:
“I’m handicapped—emotionally, financially, and spiritually, haha!”
Wrong. Now it’s a bumper sticker. You just told them where you’re going and then didn’t go there.
Good misdirection requires a clean on-ramp.
🎯 Step 4: Choose the Cleverest Twist That Benignly Violates the Norm
This is where you finally earn your laugh.
Punchline: I was born without an ass.
The audience assumed you were talking about something tragic. Something serious. And then you hit them with something specific, absurd, and benignly violating. That’s the laugh sweet spot: a surprising violation of the setup’s norm that doesn’t hurt anyone.
It’s not mean. It’s not cringey. It’s ridiculous in a way that’s still emotionally connected.
To do this, use any combination of the 36 Humor Heightening Devices. For this punchline I used Bait & Switch, Sarcasm, Exaggeration, and a bit of Sexual Innuendo.
🔧 Add Tags Using the Humor Heightening Devices
Once the punchline lands, you’re not done. You start tagging. But not randomly — with intention. You use one or more of the 36 Humor Heightening Devices I teach:
- Exaggeration:
“I slide off chairs like a cartoon banana peel.” - Anthropomorphizing:
“My jeans are just flapping in back like a bored puppet.” - Fantasy Outlet for Frustration:
“If I had a real ass, I’d slam it shut like a filing cabinet every time someone interrupts me.” - Cut Forward To:
“Cut to me at TSA getting flagged for ‘suspicious lack of cheeks.’”
Each one keeps the audience hooked, because you’re heightening a POV they now trust. You’re not chasing laughs. You’re building a bit.
Final Rule: No Jokes in the Setup. I Mean It.
Every time you put a little zinger or one-liner in your setup, you’re softening the tension you need for the punchline to land.
It’s like telling the audience, “Don’t worry, a joke’s coming!” and then… they’re already half-laughing when it hits, and the impact is gone.
Or, as comedian/author Adam Bloom puts it – you’re leaking the air out of the balloon too early.
Let the premise reveal something vulnerable.
Let the setup build quiet tension.
Let the punchline explode that tension.
Then tag it like a lunatic with the keys to the heightening factory.
Final Thought
Jokes aren’t written — they’re engineered.
This is how I build mine. Premise. Comedy Lens. Norm. Twist.
And then I crack open my big dumb toolkit of 36 ways to keep the laugh train going.
So if you’re wondering why a joke of yours isn’t working, check the blueprint.
There’s a good chance your setup is already trying too hard to be liked.
Save the funny for the part where it pays off.
That’s how pros do it.
Now good luck cracking wise.
Get your FREE copy of The Business of Comedy!
Includes:
- How Comedians are 5-Tool Players
- How to Attract a Following
- How to Get Bookings
- How to Create Multiple Income Streams
- Manager vs Agent
- And More!
It’s a shame you don’t have a donate button! I’d most certainly donate to this superb blog! I suppose for now i’ll settle for book-marking and adding your RSS feed to my Google account. I look forward to fresh updates and will share this website with my Facebook group. Chat soon!
I just visited a webpage similar to this one, but the material wasn’t as interesting as what’s here.
I’m really enjoying the theme/design of your site. Do you ever run into any internet browser compatibility issues? A couple of my blog visitors have complained about my blog not operating correctly in Explorer but looks great in Chrome. Do you have any advice to help fix this issue?
Thanks for every other informative blog. Where else could I get that kind of info written in such a perfect method? I’ve a project that I am simply now working on, and I’ve been on the look out for such information.
WONDERFUL Post.thanks for share..more wait .. ?